Features Albums Concerts Singles What's On Archives Contact @ Leave Us
S o r t e d   m a g A Z i n eArchives
Navigation Bar - Links at bottom

Tracker

:Columns::New York Diary::Sordid::Beats Per Minute::Columns:
Sordid main page
ReviewsInterviewsLinks

Sordid Reviews October-1999

form/alkaline - "disk 1.2"
form/alkaline are the artists formerly known as Scar Tissue, who were responsible for some great rhythm-based industrial soundscapes. However, they recently decided to try something new and changed their name to reflect the change. Unfortunately, the "something new" isn't all that new, it's dark ambient. For the first few tracks, there's little to distinguish form/alkaline's bleeps, drones and whirrs from those of innumerable other, similar acts, including Scorn and Black Lung. Then, from track 5 onwards, the beats pick up and form/alkaline add heavy militaristic and tribal rhythms to the mix alongside some fucked-up noise sample - sirens, screams, disjointed voices. In other words, form/alkaline become a lot more interesting when they start playing around with the same sounds that made Scar Tissue interesting. It's all very well trying something new, but I hope the band have realised that they're at their best advancing their own particular sound, rather than failing to do anything new with music that's been done before, a lot.

Back to reviews

Libitina - "A Closer Communion"
Libitina have, what you'd call, an ultra-Gothic sound. From the opening horror soundtrack sounds of 'Esclaviditud', it's obvious that innovation is not exactly their strong point, they're simply recycling the sounds of their predecessors. At the same time, it's hard to pick out who they sound like. There are shades of the Sisters and of Rozz Williams here and there, but, in general, their sound is fairly generic and more than a bit clichèd. There's the Dr. Avalanche style drum machine, the pounding bass, more than a few powerchords, the overwhelming keyboards and the overwrought vocals. Not to say it isn't enjoyable, but nothing really new. They do have a few points in their favour. The first is their tempo on tracks like 'Dies Irae' and 'Drowning in the Dark', which they play quite a bit faster than your average brooding Goth band, adding a bit of life to the proceedings. The second point is their sense of humour. Their witty parody of Pulp's 'Common People', 'Gothic People' is guaranteed to raise a smile. All in all, there's nothing particularly wrong with the CD, it's perfectly listenable, but it just doesn't have that necessary spark to make it special. Maybe next time.

Back to reviews

Luxt - "Americoncussion Demo"
Compilation veterans Luxt play a pile-driving, hard-edged mix of hardcore punk and heavy techno. Vocals are shared by Anna Christine and Erie Loch, mixing the male/female voices well. Anna's strong, bitchy sound clashes with and compliments Erie's roaring hardcore sound, preventing them from sliding into the boring repetitive sound of many new indus bands. The second track, 'Knock You Down', has a very funky, almost hip hop, vibe, which is reminiscent of vanished cross-over heroes, Senser, 'though an awful lot heavier. 'Brutal' is more melodic, though it's pumped up by a very intense guitar sound. Luxt have the intensity and musical ingenuity to stand their own against the more popular extreme industrial bands and are preparing themselves to do just that. Their next album is something that should be watched when it comes out and don't be surprised if they end up on MTV alongside Korn or Coal Chamber.

Back to reviews

man(i)kin - "sem(i)nal" (Nightbreed)
man(i)kin are one of the new generation of techno-Goth bands being pioneered by Nightbreed. Along with Inertia and Intra-Venus, man(i)kin are bringing Goth music to the dancefloor with a bang. man(i)kin are the most dance-influenced of them all, with some of the tastiest beats to be heard anywhere, including many techno acts. All forms of techno go into the mix - rave, house, trance, hints of gabba and drum n' bass, topped off with some EBM. What keeps them from being another dance act are the vocals, the morose and droning voice of Seth, which gives the music a dark, Gothic edge.
The vocals are what fix man(i)kin definitely in the world of darkwave and make them one of the more interesting and eclectic bands of the darkside. However, in the long run, this could be a disadvantage. Nailing their colours so securely to the mast will undoubtedly impact negatively on their cross-over potential. Their sound is a little too dark for your average disco. So, for now, man(i)kin can remain our little secret.

Back to reviews

Moonspell - "the butterfly effect" (Century Media)
Like many of Century Media's better bands, Moonspell are a metal band gone Goth. In comparison with many of the others, though, Moonspell haven't let go of their metal safety-blanket yet. Thus, we have a very uneasy and often unlistenable mix of melodic guitar-driven Gothic rock and awful death metal. Even worse, they sound like the silliest of cartoon doom metal bands, Cathedral, on tracks like 'butterfly fx'.
When they drop the bullshit metal posing, like on the slow and sleazy lounge lizard vibe of 'can't bee', they don't sound half bad. In fact, 'can't bee' is a very powerful slice of mature Gothic music. Unfortunately, it's a treasure buried deep in the mess that makes up much of the rest of the CD. There are a few other good moments, 'selfabuse' and 'I am the eternal spectator' are sharp clean tracks, 'selfabuse' is like an industrial track without the techno, while 'I am…' is a bizarre mix of electro rhythms, industrial distortion, metallic guitars and a piano bit that sounds like it came from Bowie's "1. Outside". 'disappear here' is more lounge lizard, though it's more upbeat than 'can't bee' with a more intense guitar line. Everything else descends into a pit of death metal noise, spoiling everything they're trying to do, until 'k' wraps the CD up with and instrumental rhythm sound that doesn't really go anywhere. Moonspell have got to make up their minds, the death metal sounds will put anybody but an ardent metalhead off. In fact, it took a few listens of the CD to realise there were some good tracks in there.

Back to reviews

Nocturne - "Twilight" (Hollows Hill)
Nocturne are young (most of them are in their early 20s), ambitious and somewhat arrogant. Their music, while it is admittedly dark, isn't the same as Goth; at least that's what they say. Surprisingly, though, they're not completely wrong. Rather than simply trying to hype their sound, they are honestly pointing out that they are not just another Banshees/Bauhaus/Sisters clone. Lead singer Lacey Connor's first gig was as support for Marilyn Manson, with her previous band, the Furies. This marks them out as a band completely tied into the pseudo-Goth scene that's grown up in the States, and largely out of the more exclusive "real" scene. They use their position in a very amorphous scene to their advantage, throwing together a wide range of influences and giving them a dark twist, without regard for what should or shouldn't be done.
At times, there are shades of the Pixies or the Throwing Muses in there, at others there's the Riot Grrrl-esque sounds of Babes In Toyland or even Daisy Chainsaw. To this they add shades of their contemporaries, bands like Genitorturers or NIN, to create a hard-hitting, sharp and sexy sound. Their sound isn't a million miles from Grace Overthrown, a band with much the same background.
There's a nice line of humour in their style, with gloriously overblown lyrics, that at times get so silly, there is no doubt this band is averse to pompousness. Tracks like 'Spookius Mortem' or 'Pride Must Die' (wittily shortened to P.M.S.) prove this without a doubt. These are laid on top of pounding rhythms, powerhouse guitars with a very seductive lyrical performance by Lacey. Nocturne, along with G/O, give hope that the current revival may not simply be Manson-inspired hype and may continue to produce enjoyable and interesting new music for some time to come.

Back to reviews

one - "walk the mercy mile" (Nightbreed)
one is the return of Goth/metal band Meridian's vocalist, David Wilkinson. "walk the mercy mile" is the follow-up to last years "Receive the Word" EP. That's the history, done, now, the music. In general, this is sharp, tasty electro-Goth, featuring 80s style synths and beats, with guitar samples ranging from lightweight decoration to powerhouse riffs that beef up the sound immensely. The one flaw with one's sound is the vocals, a lot of the time David sounds like he has a poker rammed up his arse. His singing is often reminiscent of Faith No More's Mike Patton, but with a forced, unnatural feel that grates quite a bit. However, this is not the case on all tracks, 'In the End' is the most 80s electro-style track, on which he sings rather nicely, proving that he doesn't need to try so hard. It's pretty much the same for most of the techno-influenced 'Gods of Love' until he hits the chorus and his butt-cheeks seem to clench again.
'Temple of You Soul', on the other hand, shows clearly what he's trying to do, it's like a Goth-ified version of something off FNM's "Angel Dust", but there is obvious strain in his vocals. It's surprising he doesn't burst a blood vessel. Funniest of all, though, is his constipated version of Tears for Fears' 'Shout'. Please, it's a silly pop song, but the intensity and gravitas he tries very hard to add just make it sound ridiculous. All in all, this is a promising release, but would somebody please give this guy a backrub! This is supposed to be fun, don't try so hard.

Back to reviews

Various - "Storm the Palace: Worms AD MCXVII" (Palace of Worms)
This whole classically-influenced atmospheric/ethereal malarkey has really taken off recently and has even been made sexy by the Mediæval Bæbes. Of course, with the demise of the great bands of the genre, Dead Can Dance and This Mortal Coil, there's a large void to be filled. In steps Palace of Worms with a proposition no self-respecting floaty Goth band could resist - an album based on the music and history of the Dark Ages. And so we have "Storm the Palace: Worms AD MCXVII" a flouncey, foppish, and occasionally dark, collection of assorted musics about slaughter, crusades, disease, and, of course, death. The bands lining up to spout incomprehensible Latin and ye olde Englishe include some gloriously pretentious names as Mors Syphilitica (a personal favourite), Hagalaz Runedance (sounds like a brand of ice-cream), El Luto Del Rey Cuervo and Nothvs Filivs Mortis (whew!). There are some more well-know (and easier to spell) names in there too, like Penitent, Rosa Crux, Stone 588 and Autumn Tears.
The tracks that stand out are those that sound a bit different, in particular Proscriptor's 'Our Blood and Veins from the McGovern Regiment' - a highland war romp complete with bagpipes, military drumming and some bizarre sound fx. Nothvs Filivs Mortis' 'Legio' is another, with its dark, oppressive feel. This is no reflection on the 16 other bands, each of whom acquits themselves well on the more classically-oriented music. Each and every band shows a high level of ability, both musically and, where applicable, vocally, in some cases playing music rather different from their usual style. This is a concept compilation that works very nicely and would make a great soundtrack to a book by David Eddings or Raymond E. Feist.

Back to reviews

All reviews by Girl the Goth.