It would be impossible and entirely remiss for me to review this disc
and not mention Delos International's 1997 release of Hildegard von
Bingen's work titled "Voices of Angels." At the same time, any mention
of such release is an entirely unfair comparison; Jocelyn Montgomery's
soprano is no comparison for "Voices of Angels"'s Kathy Theil. And to
be honest, not too many people are.
While "Lux Vivens" is both a beautiful disc and a beautiful idea, the
work of Abbess von Bingen is finally getting attention from popular
media after nearly 1000 years of relative obscurity, these pieces were
meant to be listened to as they were originally written - as Gregorian
chants. The instrumentation on this disc distracts from and obscures
the power of the human voice, which was meant to be the central and
sole focus of all these songs. Also, not to be a total Gregorian
chant/opera snob, the tonal "stretching" required to reach all
intended notes in these songs is nearly impossible to achieve without
classical schooling.
Montgomery has a beautiful voice, but she's not hitting half the notes
here. Like I said before, it's great that David Lynch is focusing
attention on this amazing woman and her work. The press kit and the
liner notes include much information about her history and the
contributions she made to the Church and the medieval world in a time
when women wielded little power. This is just not the way her music
was intended to be heard.
by Holly Day